Revdict.

The Hill

252 Schraalenburgh Rd, Closter, NJ 07624, United States · United States

4.4 on Google · 537 reviews · View on Google Maps

Manipulation score

Clean

Completed Jul 25, 2026 · 27 reviews flagged

How this score works

The score estimates how strongly this place's review record matches known manipulation patterns, from 0 (no signs) to 100. Verdicts: Clean below 40, Suspicious from 40, Likely Manipulated from 70; Review Drive when the flags are mostly staff asking customers for named reviews. It rises with the share of reviews flagged and how suspicious each one is.

Burst
— an abnormal spike of five-star reviews in a single day compared to the place's usual pace.
Low activity account
— the reviewer has almost no other reviews, photos, or Local Guide history; throwaway accounts look like this.
Duplicate text
— the wording is nearly identical to another review of the same place.

Verdicts are statistical estimates based on public review patterns, not accusations. Full methodology, signal definitions and known limits →

Case conclusion

What the numbers say

537 reviews examined

Google rating
4.4★

All reviews shown by Google

Not-flagged average
4.4★

510 examined reviews

Flagged
5%

27 of 537

Coverage
100%

537 of 537 Google reviews

“Not flagged” means no configured Revdict signal matched; it does not prove a review is genuine. Data fetched Jul 25, 2026.

Review brief

What reviews not flagged by Revdict say

The Hill is a contemporary restaurant in Closter, New Jersey, known for its warm, rustic-chic atmosphere and inventive menu. While many reviewers praise the sophisticated dishes, attentive service, and pleasant ambiance, a recurring group of patrons report high prices, small portions, and occasional inconsistencies in food flavor and service quality.

+ Repeated strengths

Atmosphere and Decor

Reviewers frequently highlight the restaurant's cozy, modern rustic farmhouse aesthetic and inviting outdoor patio area.

2 supporting reviews

5★ · 2018-06-14

The feel of the restaurant is exactly what the area needs, and the service was excellent. We had the Orecchiette, Calamari, and Risotto appetizers, then the grilled Octopus a NY strip and the Scallops, all cooked perfectly. The deserts were...

5★ · 2025-07-22

Fantastic service and food. Decor has a western vibe. I could imagine being in Aspen or Jackson.

Cocktails and Drinks

Reviewers report that the bar serves creative, well-crafted cocktails and a solid selection of drinks.

1 supporting review

5★ · 2025-11-29

Great place for a good moment with your loved ones. The place looks very nice. The service was good and the restaurant is spacious. The prices are normal based on the food and theme of the restaurant. Expect to spend within $50 - $100 per...

Appetizers and Seafood

Specific starters and seafood options, such as the octopus, ceviche, and tuna tartare, receive frequent praise for freshness and flavor.

2 supporting reviews

5★ · 2018-12-02

December 1, 2018 We came back this evening to shake off a bad day and it was the best thing we could have done! Everything was even better than I remembered. The restaurant is decorated for the holidays and it looks beautiful inside and out...

5★ · 2019-08-21

Our server really paid attention to all the small requests and made our experience quite delightful. The Octopus was excellent, Swordfish ok.

− Repeated complaints

High Pricing and Portion Sizes

Multiple reviewers feel that the restaurant is overpriced for the portion sizes provided and the overall quality of the meal.

3 supporting reviews

4★ · 2019-03-27

Food and drinks were great, service was too. Its a little pricey and the portions are relatively smalls.

3★ · 2021-12-12

Super pricey / small portions /meh

3★ · 2023-01-07

Very nice place, food portions are small and overall drink and food menu overpriced!

Inconsistent Food Quality

Some reviewers report receiving bland dishes, overcooked meats, or meals lacking expected seasoning.

3 supporting reviews

1★ · 2018-06-10

Tuna and Orecchiette appetizers had no taste. The bar was not capable of making simple cocktails. Panna Cotta dessert was unrecognizable. The meal underperformed and was overpriced. In fairness, soft shell crab, and service was acceptable.

3★ · 2019-06-30

The menu sounded interesting but the execution of our food was slightly off. Certain things were under seasoned, others needed more acid, and our asparagus was overcooked to mush. Drinks were good though. Unfortunately I don't think I'd...

2★ · 2026-01-01

I would pick somewhere else. Went there for Christmas Eve dinner- was very disappointed. It was 3 star service at 5 star pricing. The starters were good, but the mains tasted like they were boiled and then left under a heat lamp and the des...

Service Inconsistencies

Reviewers note instances of inattentive service, slow pacing between courses, or unaccommodating staff interactions.

3 supporting reviews

2★ · 2018-07-30

Nice atmosphere, very friendly service. Food was average, not bad, but not amazing. However, it took 40 minutes between finishing appetizers and actually getting the main course served for our party of 4. A small break in-between is fine, b...

4★ · 2021-04-08

Goes without saying lovely atmosphere and food is excellent here. For my first visit the customer service was great however, I returned yesterday (3days later) and the service wasn’t the same. Ordered drinks and water asa we sat down and wa...

1★ · 2025-02-15

You can not cancel or reschedule reservation and very nasty people on phone “trying to help”

Good for

  • Date nights and romantic dinners
  • Special occasions and celebrations
  • Enjoying drinks at a lively bar area

Avoid if

  • You are looking for budget-friendly dining
  • You expect large, filling portions for the price
  • You are sensitive to closely spaced tables and ambient noise

Recent pattern — A number of recent reviews mention that the restaurant is closing or has closed down.

Summarized from 319 text reviews not flagged by Revdict · 2018-06-09 to 2026-05-28 · Summaries can miss context; open the supporting reviews before deciding.

Review anatomy

Reviews per quarter

Reviews per quarter, total and flagged
QuarterReviewsFlagged
Q2 ’18122
Q3 ’18171
Q4 ’18161
Q1 ’19342
Q2 ’19252
Q3 ’19201
Q4 ’19272
Q1 ’20222
Q2 ’2010
Q3 ’20241
Q4 ’20171
Q1 ’21100
Q2 ’21220
Q3 ’21140
Q4 ’21231
Q1 ’22202
Q2 ’22170
Q3 ’22302
Q4 ’22100
Q1 ’23141
Q2 ’23201
Q3 ’23110
Q4 ’23160
Q1 ’24110
Q2 ’24140
Q3 ’24120
Q4 ’24150
Q1 ’25111
Q2 ’25111
Q3 ’25101
Q4 ’25100
Q1 ’26122
Q2 ’2690

Rating distribution

5★
4★
3★
2★
1★

Evidence

  • low activity account 27 reviews flagged weight 0.8

Flagged reviews

Showing the 10 most suspicious of 27 flagged reviews.

Ann Lierman profile photo

Ann Lierman

1 review

★★★★★

2018-06-17

The restaurant is beautiful. You have to try the calamari. The chickpea salad is so fresh and delicious. For main course try the pork chop,so flavorful and juicy. The octopus is the best that we've ever had. Servers are friendly and knowledgeable.
low activity account suspicion 48
Minaxi Jhawer profile photo

Minaxi Jhawer

2 reviews

★★★★★

2018-06-29

low activity account suspicion 48
Anna Thoma profile photo

Anna Thoma

2 reviews

★★★★★

2018-10-28

low activity account suspicion 48
Chris Suh profile photo

Chris Suh

2 reviews

★★★★★

2019-01-12

low activity account suspicion 48
Atad Sapir profile photo

Atad Sapir

1 review

★★★★★

2019-04-13

low activity account suspicion 48
Jackie Roem profile photo

Jackie Roem

1 review

★★★★★

2019-04-27

It was fantastic.
low activity account suspicion 48
Mark Milman profile photo

Mark Milman

2 reviews

★★★★★

2019-10-05

low activity account suspicion 48
Louis Piuggi profile photo

Louis Piuggi

2 reviews

★★★★★

2020-01-04

low activity account suspicion 48
Esmeralda Rosario profile photo

Esmeralda Rosario

2 reviews

★★★★★

2020-03-02

This place is amazing!! Totally recommend it. I celebrated my daughter’s sweet 16 there this weekend and I am in awe of everything. They are beyond accommodating. The food was delicious. My family was raving about it. The service is to the extreme. Thank you so much to all at The Hill!!!
low activity account suspicion 48
Lucca Mezzapelli profile photo

Lucca Mezzapelli

2 reviews

★★★★★

2020-08-10

low activity account suspicion 48

Report generated Jul 25, 2026. Reviews change — you can request a fresh investigation.

More investigations in United States