Eataly - Flatiron

5★ · 2025-07-30

We went for lunch here during office hours. You walk through a nice Italian supermarket to reach this restaurant which is under the same roof. Its right opposite the Madison Park. I went for the set lunch menu which was truly bang for the b...

4★ · 2025-08-31

Ordered an affogato and gelato (flavors stracciatella and caramel)! The gelato was very light and creamy! The affogato was delicious as well but the cup size for the affogato was a bit misleading as it was only filled half way…still good t...

5★ · 2025-07-31

Had a lovely lunch here during a city visit! The vibe was warm and lively - felt like a quick trip to Italy.

5★ · 2025-12-17

Little pricey, but really good products. Try it !

5★ · 2026-06-02

One of my favorite Eataly’s in the world honestly. You’re in the heart of NYC, next to the Flatiron and gorgeous Madison Square Park. And this place is like a Narnia’s Wardrobe into real Italian culinary culture. I like how neat it is insid...

5★ · 2025-08-07

Amazing food. Loved the Ravioli pasta and the white wine. Phillip the server was superb in service, very aware of what you need. Must visit

5★ · 2025-09-02

My family and I had a great dinner in Eataly, Flat Iron location. Our server, Antonio, helped make the dinner a huge success. His professionalism, his attitude, and his attentiveness were exemplary. We had a two year old and a four year old...

1★ · 2025-07-19

I hadn't been to New York for a few years. I went there often for work and ate here frequently. I returned to Eataly NYC Flatiron in July of this year. My wife and I ordered two pizzas and two bottles of San Benedetto sparkling water. The p...

1★ · 2025-08-01

Nice but expensive, very expensive, very expensive. The food is absolutely not worth the price!!! Go eat somewhere else for much less money.

3★ · 2025-12-03

Eataly is an amazing place and I’ve always loved it, but the prices have gone up so dramatically that it now feels unreasonable. Paying almost thirty dollars for a sandwich or a simple bowl of pasta is honestly shocking. Pasta costs a coupl...

1★ · 2025-07-23

Hot and sweaty, tremendous noise and overpriced mediocre food. We came here on Jul 9, it was like a hothouse; it's a rooftop with a glass ceiling and no AC, maybe just 1 fan; the plants that are decorating it don't help much. Our waiter was...

5★ · 2025-08-22

It was very crowded and full of people! I never got to try these yogurt and I only got to take a good photo of these two 🥲 there was sale going on when I went there (it was 2month ago) I love Eataly and it’s one of my go to places! I reall...

3★ · 2025-12-07

For me, is always too crowded and there's too much going on and it has a factory grocery store vibe, and for me I could never really feel calm there. I don't understand how people eat right in the middle of all of the shoppers. And I'm from...

3★ · 2025-08-17

Stopped by Eataly because it was super close to our hotel and we enjoyed the one in lower Manhattan. Went to the pizza + pasta restaurant inside because of the reviews for gluten free pizza were so good. My wife has celiac, so I love any ti...

3★ · 2025-09-05

We had lunch here today and the experience was disappointing. We weren’t given the prix-fixe lunch menu until we specifically asked for it (arrived around 3pm). The fixed menu only had one meat-free option (cacio e pepe), but we were told t...