Revdict.

Ellen's Stardust Diner

Diner · 1650 Broadway, New York, NY 10019, United States · United States

4.4 on Google · 24,424 reviews · View on Google Maps

Manipulation score

Clean

Completed Jul 15, 2026 · 55 reviews flagged

How this score works

The score estimates how strongly this place's review record matches known manipulation patterns, from 0 (no signs) to 100. Verdicts: Clean below 40, Suspicious from 40, Likely Manipulated from 70; Review Drive when the flags are mostly staff asking customers for named reviews. It rises with the share of reviews flagged and how suspicious each one is.

Burst
— an abnormal spike of five-star reviews in a single day compared to the place's usual pace.
Low activity account
— the reviewer has almost no other reviews, photos, or Local Guide history; throwaway accounts look like this.
Duplicate text
— the wording is nearly identical to another review of the same place.

Verdicts are statistical estimates based on public review patterns, not accusations. Full methodology, signal definitions and known limits →

Case conclusion

What the numbers say

999 reviews examined

Google rating
4.4★

All reviews shown by Google

Not-flagged average
4.4★

944 examined reviews

Flagged
6%

55 of 999

Coverage
4%

999 of 24,424 Google reviews

“Not flagged” means no configured Revdict signal matched; it does not prove a review is genuine. Data fetched Jul 15, 2026.

Review brief

What reviews not flagged by Revdict say

Ellen's Stardust Diner offers a unique and high-energy dining experience featuring talented singing waitstaff who perform Broadway-style songs throughout the meal. While visitors consistently praise the lively entertainment and welcoming atmosphere, many note that the food is fairly average and prices are high.

+ Repeated strengths

Talented Singing Staff and Atmosphere

Reviewers frequently highlight the incredible vocal talent and high-energy performances of the singing waitstaff, creating a fun, immersive Broadway-style environment.

3 supporting reviews

5★ · 2026-02-05

Fantastic experience. You get a mini Broadway show while the actual actors/singers take your order and bring you your food. The ambiance is awesome and the guys and gals are all super talented. I'm totally repeating the experience when I go...

5★ · 2026-02-21

​If you’re wondering if the line wrapping around the block is worth it—it absolutely is. Ellen’s Stardust Diner delivers exactly what it promises: classic, hearty traditional diner food served with a side of world-class talent. The atmosphe...

4★ · 2026-06-17

It's primarily an activity before it's a place to eat; you know that when you go there, you're not just paying for the food, but for the singing too! The food is good, but nothing special, but the portions are enormous. We ordered one dish...

Generous Portions

Reviewers report that the meals and side dishes come in large, filling portions.

2 supporting reviews

5★ · 2026-02-12

Worth doing both for the atmosphere and for the incredibly generous traditional meal – we couldn't finish!

5★ · 2026-02-27

Fun place with great artists. Generous portions. Relaxed, family-friendly atmosphere.

Fun Family Experience

Guests note that the lively and interactive show is particularly enjoyable for families, children, and groups.

2 supporting reviews

5★ · 2026-02-17

Took my 4 and 2 year old for lunch on a Sunday where they had a blast. Energy was great, staff was mostly friendly and some very good singers. Food was better than expected for such a tourist location. Great "staycation" option for new york...

5★ · 2026-02-20

Great place to be with your family. Love the atmosphere, music, and service. Very talented people.

− Repeated complaints

Mediocre Food Quality

Reviewers report that the food is basic, bland, or underwhelming relative to the prices.

3 supporting reviews

2★ · 2026-02-07

Food was served barely warm. Hamburger had no seasoning on it whatsoever. Had to ask for ketchup mayonnaise mustard for my hamburger. French fries were good. Caesar salad was good. Singers were fun to listen to would’ve loved some songs oth...

3★ · 2026-02-25

It fell short of my expectations (I think I had overly high expectations for a professional performance). However, it was a refreshing experience to enjoy the fresh and unique atmosphere. Perhaps because the work was so demanding, the serve...

3★ · 2026-04-04

Grew up in NYC & have never gone. Big disappointment! Food was your usual frozen chain restaurant quality. Seating is VERY TIGHT and we were seated at this make shift counter near the kitchen. During the performances/singing this woman came...

Long Wait Times and Crowds

Reviewers report long lines and waits outside, as well as tight, cramped seating arrangements indoors.

2 supporting reviews

2★ · 2026-02-18

HUGE tourist trap. The lack of transparency about wait times is the kiss of death. The food and atmosphere are absolutely not worth the wait in line - particularly while being repeatedly told by employees "we can't give an approximate wait...

4★ · 2026-03-01

The first time I came 10 years ago I would have given it a 5 star, but this last time I wasn't horribly impressed. Even outside of peak hours we still had a 90+ minute wait due to two large school tours being ahead of us. The food was fine,...

Tipping Policies and Pushy Solicitations

Reviewers report frustration over automatically included service charges, high prices, and frequent requests for extra donations via a passed bucket.

3 supporting reviews

2★ · 2026-02-07

Food was alright, Atmosphere was funny. BUT. The waiters were very slow. We gave ours a 10$ (18%) Tip because she was quite friendly. Though later on the bill we found out that the store takes already 20% Tip on your bill themselves without...

3★ · 2026-02-24

Pretty unique experience, but it's a 3/5 for a few reasons: 1. The MC was very, very chatty, and he kept asking for money with a bucket every 30 minutes or so. It was a little much. 2. The food is not cheap, and the quality doesn't really...

2★ · 2026-04-13

AUTOMATIC 20% tip that they hide in fine print and don’t even tell you, you can REMOVE. Make sure to remove the tip on the receipt. Also such cheap people, asked for DONATIONS at the end after charging $35 for chicken and waffles 😂

Good for

  • Musical theater fans and visitors looking for a uniquely entertaining New York show experience
  • Families and groups wanting a lively, highly energetic atmosphere
  • Travelers prioritizing a memorable performance over gourmet dining

Avoid if

  • You are looking for a quiet meal where you can easily converse
  • You are sensitive to very loud music and cramped seating
  • You expect high-end, gourmet culinary quality for the price
Summarized from 666 text reviews not flagged by Revdict · 2026-01-30 to 2026-07-15 · Summaries can miss context; open the supporting reviews before deciding.

Review anatomy

Reviews per month

Reviews per month, total and flagged
MonthReviewsFlagged
Jan ’26120
Feb ’261473
Mar ’2618413
Apr ’2620918
May ’262054
Jun ’261589
Jul ’26848

Rating distribution

5★
4★
3★
2★
1★

Evidence

  • low activity account 51 reviews flagged weight 0.8
  • duplicate text 2 reviews flagged weight 0.9
  • generic account 2 reviews flagged weight 1

Flagged reviews

Exhibit — 2 reviews, near-identical wording

Pretty fun and chill vibes, can't belive I've never been here before! got here before 6pm on a weekday night and waited in line for about 20 minutes, it's easier to get seats for 2 but fine with groups of 4 as well (party of 6 might have longer wait time), the waiters and waitresses will take turns...
  • Rita L ★★★★ 2026-03-04 suspicion 85
  • Hammad Ansari ★★ 2026-03-16 suspicion 85

Showing the 10 most suspicious of 53 remaining flagged reviews.

Somya Gupta profile photo

Somya Gupta

41 reviews · Local Guide

★★★★★

2026-04-01

The best dining experience of my life. You have actual Broadway actors performing and serving you. It can't get more New York than this. I went here during my birthday and our server was Ryan. He was the kindest and the coolest waiter you can ask for. I will be here again.
generic account suspicion 85
Samanta Patarini profile photo

Samanta Patarini

42 reviews · Local Guide

★★★★★

2026-07-07

I've been to NYC four times and I've returned every time! The experience of this diner with the waiters singing between courses is a must-do on any trip! The waiters are excellent singers. Excellent food and good prices, just steps from Times Square!
generic account suspicion 85
Andrea Robang profile photo

Andrea Robang

2 reviews

★☆☆☆☆

2026-02-02

low activity account suspicion 48
Molly DuBois profile photo

Molly DuBois

1 review

★★★★★

2026-02-19

Out of the two times I’ve went there each time they’re polite and give great service!!!!
low activity account suspicion 48
Evan Janiec profile photo

Evan Janiec

1 review

★★★★★

2026-02-19

The food was good! The staff were awesome. It was fun eating there! I recommend this spot!
low activity account suspicion 48
Sabina Gordi profile photo

Sabina Gordi

2 reviews

★★★★★

2026-03-05

low activity account suspicion 48
Zniesmaczony _ profile photo

Zniesmaczony _

2 reviews

★★★★★

2026-03-11

low activity account suspicion 48
Susan O'Herron profile photo

Susan O'Herron

1 review

★★★★★

2026-03-13

low activity account suspicion 48
virginie el mehdi profile photo

virginie el mehdi

2 reviews

★☆☆☆☆

2026-03-13

Utterly disappointing service!!!!! We were asked to change tables because the one they had seated us at was next to the door. We changed seats and waited for our sixth guest. We ordered our milkshakes, and the managers weren't happy with our order (a young woman with long curly hair, petite, and a n...
low activity account suspicion 48
Aaron Walters profile photo

Aaron Walters

1 review

★★★★★

2026-03-15

Absolutely amazing time here! Every time we visit NYC we visit Ellen’s for the great shows and food.
low activity account suspicion 48

Report generated Jul 15, 2026. Reviews change — you can request a fresh investigation.

More investigations in United States