Revdict.

The Smith

American restaurant · 1150 Broadway, New York, NY 10010, United States · United States

4.4 on Google · 6,347 reviews · View on Google Maps

Manipulation score

Clean

Completed Jul 15, 2026 · 57 reviews flagged

How this score works

The score estimates how strongly this place's review record matches known manipulation patterns, from 0 (no signs) to 100. Verdicts: Clean below 40, Suspicious from 40, Likely Manipulated from 70; Review Drive when the flags are mostly staff asking customers for named reviews. It rises with the share of reviews flagged and how suspicious each one is.

Burst
— an abnormal spike of five-star reviews in a single day compared to the place's usual pace.
Low activity account
— the reviewer has almost no other reviews, photos, or Local Guide history; throwaway accounts look like this.
Duplicate text
— the wording is nearly identical to another review of the same place.

Verdicts are statistical estimates based on public review patterns, not accusations. Full methodology, signal definitions and known limits →

Case conclusion

What the numbers say

1,000 reviews examined

Google rating
4.4★

All reviews shown by Google

Not-flagged average
4.5★

943 examined reviews

Flagged
6%

57 of 1,000

Coverage
16%

1,000 of 6,347 Google reviews

“Not flagged” means no configured Revdict signal matched; it does not prove a review is genuine. Data fetched Jul 15, 2026.

Review brief

What reviews not flagged by Revdict say

Reviewers report that The Smith offers a lively atmosphere and a varied menu of American comfort food, with many highlighting standout items like burgers, pasta, and the sticky toffee pudding. While many guests praise the attentive service and overall dining experience, others note that the large, tile-heavy space can become quite loud.

+ Repeated strengths

Food Quality and Variety

Reviewers frequently praise the delicious food, highlighting favorites such as burgers, pasta dishes, and desserts like the sticky toffee pudding.

3 supporting reviews

5★ · 2024-06-20

The buratta appetizer was a really standout with its well seasoned cooked vegetables. And the desserts were decadent, especially the toffee pudding and s'mores in a jar.

5★ · 2024-06-20

Went twice for dinner and their burgers are great! The service is quick and friendly.

5★ · 2024-07-16

Wonderful date night spot! My husband and I had been meaning to check out this place snd finally did. Wish we would have sooner! The food here is excellent! We shared the calamari for an app that was a fun fusion of Thai with classic calama...

Service

Many guests describe the staff as friendly, professional, and attentive, often noting prompt assistance even during busy times.

3 supporting reviews

5★ · 2024-06-23

The service is beyond 5 stars. I walk in and the maitre D - Noah was very professional. The restaurant was busy but he made sure we are seated in the area we wanted. There was a miscommunication and My husband’s burger was under cooked. One...

5★ · 2024-07-23

Arrived for a walk-in dinner with a friend from out of town. Our server Maddy was attentive, patient when we were taking too much time, and very familiar with the menu. Her recommendations were spot on and the service was comfortably speedy...

5★ · 2024-07-28

Absolutely fantastic experience at The Smith, thanks to our waiter Bryan. His service was exceptional from start to finish. He was attentive, knowledgeable about the menu, and ensured we had everything we needed without ever feeling rushed....

Atmosphere and Drinks

Reviewers enjoy the lively energy, cool ambiance, and well-crafted cocktail and drink selections.

3 supporting reviews

5★ · 2024-07-02

The atmosphere at this place is definitely awesome. Our server was great and the food was good had a few drinks. Happy hours very good price I recommend this place very much the place is very nice and elegant

5★ · 2024-09-06

Me and family decided to try this place out and I am very pleased that we did. Our server was super friendly and knowledgeable about the menu and was able to recommend some great dishes. Our food was absolutely delicious and we loved the vi...

5★ · 2025-08-06

The Smith feels like a place where you can kick back anywhere—from meeting friends for cocktails and appetizers to catching brunch or post-show dinner without fuss. The energy is positive and energetic—not pretentious—making it perfect if y...

− Repeated complaints

Noise Level

Multiple reviewers report that the restaurant is very loud due to its open layout and lack of sound-absorbing materials, making conversation difficult.

2 supporting reviews

5★ · 2024-07-16

Excellent food at fair prices. Large portions. A bit noisy in the restaurant.

4★ · 2024-07-16

A little loud, but the food and service was good lots of people but was seated fast. Not much sound absorbing materials so when it was busy it was hard to carry on a conversation for people who have a bit of a hearing problem.

Inconsistent Service and Wait Times

Some guests complain about slow service, long wait times even with reservations, and inattentive staff.

2 supporting reviews

4★ · 2024-11-16

Beautiful restaurant. The 🍔 burger is definitely as good as they say and comes with a huge amount of fries. We made a reservation but they sat us almost 45 minutes after our reservation time, which was a little disappointing. We also got...

2★ · 2024-09-23

I recently visited The Smith, and unfortunately, my experience was far from positive. The server assigned to our table was incredibly lazy and inattentive, never checking back with us after taking our order. When I ordered a Shirley Temple...

Pricing and Value

A few reviewers feel that certain dishes are overpriced relative to their portion size or quality.

3 supporting reviews

4★ · 2024-07-16

Too expensive for brunch

4★ · 2024-12-06

Great everything just pricey. $26 burger

3★ · 2025-07-27

It's alright at best! The food is a bit too pricy. A salad for 35 dollars is just too much. Other places can offer the same quality for like half the price. Why should my bowl of lettuce cost me 30 bucks? What type of lettuce is it?

Good for

  • Lively group dinners and social gatherings
  • Pre- or post-theater meals near Lincoln Center
  • Classic American comfort food and weekend brunch

Avoid if

  • You prefer a quiet, intimate environment for conversation
  • You are sensitive to high noise levels and crowded spaces
  • You are looking for budget-friendly dining options
Summarized from 656 text reviews not flagged by Revdict · 2024-06-14 to 2026-07-12 · Summaries can miss context; open the supporting reviews before deciding.

Review anatomy

Reviews per month

Reviews per month, total and flagged
MonthReviewsFlagged
Jun ’24263
Jul ’24413
Aug ’24310
Sep ’24440
Oct ’24290
Nov ’24443
Dec ’24543
Jan ’25423
Feb ’25272
Mar ’25503
Apr ’25410
May ’25401
Jun ’25463
Jul ’25330
Aug ’25400
Sep ’25426
Oct ’25462
Nov ’25462
Dec ’25463
Jan ’26361
Feb ’26353
Mar ’26435
Apr ’26370
May ’26354
Jun ’26375
Jul ’2692

Rating distribution

5★
4★
3★
2★
1★

Evidence

  • low activity account 46 reviews flagged weight 0.8
  • generic account 11 reviews flagged weight 1

Flagged reviews

Showing the 10 most suspicious of 57 flagged reviews.

Roxane Duchamp profile photo

Roxane Duchamp

261 reviews · Local Guide

★★★★★

2025-09-07

They make dishes that need no justification. They match ingredients in interesting ways. The employees were cordial and quick to respond. Reliable, great quality food, very friendly staff. I'm fond of this spot and will visit again.
generic account suspicion 85
Dianne Simmons profile photo

Dianne Simmons

273 reviews · Local Guide

★★★★★

2025-10-03

This represents the height of quality. The employees genuinely made us feel right at home. You'll probably enjoy coming back here. Their food maintains high standards across all offerings. This restaurant has a wonderful environment.
generic account suspicion 85
Lloyd Holmes profile photo

Lloyd Holmes

240 reviews · Local Guide

★★★★★

2025-10-28

I didn't believe food could taste this amazing. Staff members demonstrate great manners and friendliness too. Their cooking demonstrates true skill. The staff treats you well, meals taste great, and serving sizes satisfy. I can't wait to try the whole menu!
generic account suspicion 85
Ed David profile photo

Ed David

331 reviews · Local Guide

★★★★★

2025-11-03

Great food and great atmosphere love it
generic account suspicion 85
Brandon Forbes profile photo

Brandon Forbes

14 reviews · Local Guide

★★★★★

2026-03-02

Went in without any big expectations, and wow, was I pleasantly surprised. The staff were super attentive without being over the top, and the food… wow. Everyone at our table loved what they ordered. I got the chicken milanese, and it was cooked perfectly—crispy on the outside, tender inside. Honest...
generic account suspicion 85
Latoya McCalla profile photo

Latoya McCalla

133 reviews · Local Guide

★★★★★

2026-05-03

generic account suspicion 85
James Cooke profile photo

James Cooke

14 reviews · Local Guide

★★★★★

2026-06-18

We kicked things off with drinks—bourbon for me, nice and smooth. To start eating, we went for the spicy salmon tartare, which had a good kick and felt really fresh. From there we shared a mix of dishes: the classic French dip sandwich, chicken Milanese, and some roasted green peppers on the side. I...
generic account suspicion 85
Susan V profile photo

Susan V

120 reviews · Local Guide

★★★★★

2026-06-22

It was pretty quiet the night we were there, as most folks were in the streets watching the Knicks win! Service was great, food awesome, we tried a variety of starters and sandwiches. Highly recommend.
generic account suspicion 85
jaki pol profile photo

jaki pol

45 reviews · Local Guide

★★★★★

2026-06-27

The restaurant was packed when we visited, but our meals arrived much sooner than expected. The team kept everything moving smoothly without making anyone feel rushed. The staff was warm, polite, and stopped by a few times to make sure we had everything we needed. It was nice to see such great servi...
generic account suspicion 85
nick pol profile photo

nick pol

42 reviews · Local Guide

★★★★★

2026-06-27

We kicked things off with the spicy salmon tartare, which was fresh and had a nice kick to it. From there we tried a classic French dip sandwich, chicken Milanese, and some roasted green peppers on the side. I also had a glass of Cabernet Sauvignon that paired really well with everything. Every dish...
generic account suspicion 85

Report generated Jul 15, 2026. Reviews change — you can request a fresh investigation.

More investigations in United States